Praising and Challenging A Dog Figurines Artist
Be careful raising the touchy subject of price. After
several decades, painter Joyce Korotkin still remembers the potential
buyer who inquired about the cost of her drawings. “$30?”
the buyer huffed. “For $30 I can buy a pocketbook!”
Similarly, stifle the urge to compare the artist’s work with
your own yearnings to paint or draw. “When I retire, I’m
going to learn to paint” is not a remark many artists appreciate
hearing. The implication is that art is a hobby—an implication
that particularly rankles women. “People sometimes don’t
take you seriously because they think art is something women do in their
spare time,” says fiber artist Jean Bass.
Intonation is critical in a conversation with an artist. “Iiiinteresting”
can mean one thing; “Interesting!” another. And an “interesting”
flung at a piece in careless afterthought can feel as disparaging as
describing a blind date as having a “good personality.”
Resist the urge to fixate on materials or method; while the way artists
communicate their ideas is indeed important, the ideas themselves are
their central concern. Just ask sculptor Haim Steinbach, who combines
everyday objects in his “shelf sculptures” in order to tweak
perceptions about language and cultural customs. The only question one
viewer could summon was: “How did you make those plastic goblets?”
And never ask artists how long it took to make a work of art. “No
matter what your response, you can’t win,” says Rogers.
“If you admit to completing the piece in just a few hours, your
questioner is filled with suspicion about your ability to explore a
subject with any depth, build up a rich surface, or justify the price.
If you say it took months, they worry for you because you are so slow.”
Remember that artists invest a great deal of themselves in their work;
try to respect that effort, even if you can’t admire the work
itself. Installation artist Bethany Bristow was celebrating the opening
of the exhibition “Greater New York” at New York’s
P.S.1 Contemporary Art Center when she saw a visitor kicking at one
of her fragile assemblages of glass, feathers, and corn syrup, tucked
into various corners of the building. “That’s my work!”
she shrieked. “Really?” the culprit asked. “I thought
it was junk.”
But false praise can feel as damning as outright criticism. Painter
Rochelle Feinstein noticed that people mystified by her pictures tended
to conclude studio visits with the same pronouncement: “I love
your work.” She eventually funneled her frustration into a series
of eight large Love Vibe paintings on which “love your work”
was scrawled backward.
So now you’re even more nervous than ever about talking to artists.
So what do you say? First, realize that even the experts—dealers,
curators, other artists—make their own faux pas. Painter Michelle
Stuart was visited a number of years ago by a dealer who “buzzed
around my studio and told me, ‘I have two sensitives already.’
Then he left!” A Chelsea dealer asked Shari Mendelson during a
recent visit to her sculpture studio, “So can you tell me the
social, historical, and political implications of your work?”
And Rick Briggs vividly recalls another artist commenting that his own
work was “about ideas”—in contrast, supposedly, to
Briggs’s abstract paintings.
Often, being quiet in front of a work is the best response; it indicates
that you’re looking carefully and are thinking about what you’re
seeing. When you consider that it can take weeks, months—even
years—to make an art object, looking hard is a respectful thing
to do. “I appreciate people who have obviously been moved by my
work and just want to get a sense for who I am,” says painter
Art Zoller-Wagner. “Sometimes they don’t ask a question;
they’re just relating.”
Open-ended questions are also welcomed: Who influences you? Why do
you work at this scale? Why did you start painting patterns? are questions
painter Vicki Behm likes to hear. Joanne Mattera prefers such queries
as, How do you know when a series is finished? She says, “the
question lets me talk about, in general, why I work in series, and,
in particular, how a series developed from painting to painting and
what catalyzed its completion.” And Rachel Willis adds that a
simple “‘How did you make that?’ would be fine too.”
Feinstein’s favorite comment came from a viewer contemplating
her in-your-face “love your work” installation. “I
love your work,” offered the viewer—who then caught herself
and exclaimed, “Oh, no. Now I can’t say that, can I?”
She completely understood the intent of the pictures, Feinstein realized:
“That I really appreciated.”
Gallery partner Jenny Liu, of New York’s The Project, notes that
artists tend to fall into two camps: “creative originators who
are inspired to make original and authentic sculpture/painting/drawing”
and those who consider themselves “art producers along more intellectual
lines.” To artists of the first category, a thoughtful visitor
might say, “Your work is so passionate/emotional/sad. Where does
that come from?” To the second: “Your work is so rigorous/difficult/challenging.
What are you hoping to accomplish?”
Technology-based artist Patrick Lichty appreciates audiences that challenge
his ideas. “Where do you get off?” is a question he likes.
“I believe that learning often happens through disagreement,”
he says. Conceptual artist Rachel Perry Welty agrees: “The best
question would be one that helps me think more deeply about the work
and makes me see connections I hadn’t, or puts it into a broader
context. I wish someone would dare ask me, ‘Why do you do what
you do?’” And for some, such as installation artist Ann
Hamilton, the same question can qualify as both worst and best. “What
does the horsehair mean?” is one that she has long remembered.